Tomorrow, April 5th, we will see the return of CSS Naked Day a novel idea where participating sites will remove all styling information in an effort to promote standards, get a little self promotion, and have a little fun. My take, reposted from the discussion at webstandards.org, is below. I said a bit more about it last year in I’m Not Naked, most of which still applies.
It’s meant to illustrate the importance of CSS and graceful degradation.
My interpretation on it is that it is meant to illustrate the importance of good HTML and markup practices as much as anything else — that CSS is great, but it should overshadow it all. Or maybe that’s just my own philosophy bleeding through. I surely would have called it “Naked HTML day” had I thought the idea up, and explicitly included scripting in the “stripped” category.
Let us also be clear, the group of participants in this event are self selecting, that is no one is forcing a site to remove their CSS [and perhaps other features such as JS that may manipulate style information]. Therefore I don’t see some of the objections to the promotion holding much water, or at least are made up of valid but misdirected concerns.
The maintainers and stakeholders of the sites participating shouldn’t do so lightly, but probably are not, and I would also suspect they aren’t doing so without considering all of the problems involved. And for the rare few that are participating for other motives [e.g. publicity alone] perhaps seeing their work in the unstyled state will lead to improvements.
And for the record, neither of my personal sites will be involved again this year. For most other sites I work on the group of stake holders is far too large to get a change like this through for what is primarily a social or quasi-political statement with little concrete benefits. But that’s the corporate world for you.
Comments Temporarily(?) Removed